Booking System Comparison: CodeCasa vs Acuity vs Setmore
Choosing a booking system is critical. Get it wrong, and you're stuck with something clunky that your customers hate. Get it right, and it pays for itself immediately. Let's compare the big players head-to-head.
The Contenders
| Feature | CodeCasa | Acuity | Setmore |
|---|---|---|---|
| Pricing | £49-149/mo | £15-25/mo | Free-£8/mo |
| Setup Time | 24 hours | 3-5 days | 2-3 hours |
| Mobile Experience | Excellent | Good | Fair |
| Branding | Full white-label | Limited | Limited |
| Payment Processing | Built-in (Stripe) | Separate integration | Separate integration |
| SMS Reminders | Included | £5+ extra | No |
| Multi-Staff | Yes (unlimited) | Yes | Limited |
| Custom Fields | Yes | Yes | No |
| Support | Email + Chat | Email + Phone | Email + Chat |
Deep Dive: The Real Story
Acuity Scheduling
The Hype: "The most powerful booking system on the market"
What You Get: Incredible customization. Workflows, automations, integrations galore. If you need it, Acuity probably has it.
The Reality: All that power requires setup. You'll spend hours configuring things. Their interface is powerful but overwhelming. New users often feel lost.
Best For: Agencies and businesses that live in spreadsheets and want to automate complex workflows.
Hidden Costs: SMS reminders cost extra. Payment processing requires separate setup. Staff access is limited on cheaper plans.
Setmore
The Hype: "Free appointment booking software"
What You Get: A free/cheap booking page. Works. No frills, no setup headaches.
The Reality: The free version has serious limits. Two staff members maximum. No SMS reminders. Mobile experience feels dated. Customers see "Powered by Setmore" branding.
Best For: Solo practitioners (one stylist, one therapist, etc.) who just need something quick and free.
Hidden Costs: Free until you need SMS (£12+/mo), or need more than 2 staff (£4+/mo). The UI is not mobile-optimized, so you lose conversions.
CodeCasa Bookings
The Pitch: "Built specifically for service businesses. Fast setup. Fully branded. Includes everything."
What You Get: Modern booking system designed for salons, gyms, clinics. Everything included: reminders, payments, staff management, white-label branding. Live in 24 hours.
The Reality: Pricing is higher because everything is included (no surprise fees). Interface is clean and easy. Mobile-first design. You own the entire customer experience.
Best For: Service businesses that want to look professional, scale quickly, and not worry about integration hell or hidden fees.
Hidden Costs: None. SMS, payments, staff access—all included.
The Real-World Scenarios
Scenario 1: You're a Solo Salon Owner
Best choice: Setmore (free) or CodeCasa (professional look at £49/mo)
If you want free and don't care about branding: Setmore. If you want to look professional: CodeCasa at £49/mo pays for itself in 1-2 bookings.
Scenario 2: You Have a 3-Person Team
Best choice: CodeCasa (£99/mo)
Setmore gets expensive fast with multiple staff. Acuity's setup complexity isn't worth it. CodeCasa handles teams seamlessly at £99/mo with SMS included.
Scenario 3: You're Growth-Focused
Best choice: CodeCasa (£99-149/mo)
You need SMS reminders (60% reduction in no-shows). You need beautiful branding. You need to scale without stress. CodeCasa is built for growth.
Scenario 4: You Want Maximum Flexibility
Best choice: Acuity (£15-25/mo + extras)
You're willing to invest setup time for infinite customization. Budget: £40-60/mo once you add SMS + integrations.
Total Cost of Ownership (Year 1)
Setmore (Free Plan)
- • Software: £0
- • SMS add-ons: £0 (no SMS)
- • Time to setup: 2 hours (your time = £50-100)
- • Total: ~£50-100
Acuity (Basic Plan + SMS)
- • Software: £15/mo x 12 = £180
- • SMS add-on: £5/mo x 12 = £60
- • Time to setup: 10 hours (£250-500)
- • Payment integration: variable
- • Total: £490-740
CodeCasa (Professional Plan)
- • Software: £99/mo x 12 = £1,188
- • Includes: SMS, payments, staff management
- • Time to setup: 1 hour (£25-50)
- • Total: £1,213-1,238
CodeCasa costs more upfront. But it generates ROI immediately through increased bookings and time savings.
The Bottom Line
Setmore: If you're truly solo and have zero budget, it works. But you'll regret the lack of SMS reminders (losing 15-20% of bookings to no-shows).
Acuity: If you love customization and don't mind complexity, it's powerful. But setup is a beast.
CodeCasa: If you want to launch fast, look professional, and not deal with setup hell, it's the obvious choice. Live in 24 hours. Everything included.
Try CodeCasa For Free
No credit card. No risk. See why service businesses choose CodeCasa.
🎉 50% OFF first 3 months (limited time).
Start Your Free TrialCompare for yourself. Make the right choice for your business.